Understanding Isaiah 11—and indeed all Scripture—requires us to interpret it in light of the whole Bible, particularly through the lens of Christ’s person and work.
The debate between amillennial and premillennial interpretations ultimately hinges on which approach best reflects the overarching themes of Scripture, God’s redemptive purposes, and the way New Testament authors handle Old Testament prophecy.
Here’s the evidence supporting the amillennial (i.e., spiritual) reading of Isaiah 11, showing why it aligns more faithfully with God’s intent as revealed in Scripture.
The New Testament Interprets Old Testament Prophecies Spiritually in Christ
The New Testament is the clearest evidence for a Christ-centered, spiritual reading of Isaiah 11.
The apostles and New Testament authors consistently reinterpret Old Testament prophecies through the lens of Christ’s life, death, resurrection, and reign, rather than expecting a strictly literal fulfillment.
Examples:
- Romans 15:12 explicitly cites Isaiah 11:10 and applies it to Jesus as the one in whom the Gentiles hope. Paul sees this prophecy fulfilled in the inclusion of the Gentiles in the Church through the gospel, not in a future political kingdom centered in Israel.
- Ephesians 2:14-16 describes Christ as breaking down the dividing wall between Jews and Gentiles, uniting them into one people. This fulfills the “gathering of the nations” described in Isaiah 11 in a spiritual sense within the Church.
The New Testament writers teach us to see Jesus as the fulfillment of all Old Testament promises (Luke 24:27, 44; 2 Corinthians 1:20).
Their consistent spiritual application of prophecy demonstrates that Isaiah 11 is about Christ’s redemptive kingdom, not a future earthly millennium.
Christ’s Kingdom Is Spiritual in Nature
Jesus Himself repeatedly taught that His kingdom is not of this world (John 18:36). This doesn’t mean it has no real-world effects but that it transcends political and physical boundaries.
The amillennial interpretation respects this principle by understanding Isaiah 11 as describing the spiritual realities of Christ’s reign rather than a geopolitical future.
Considerations:
- Christ’s First Coming: Isaiah 11 describes a kingdom marked by righteousness, peace, and justice. These began with Christ’s first coming. His miracles (e.g., healing the sick, raising the dead) were signs of the kingdom breaking into the world, reversing the effects of sin and the curse.
- The Already/Not Yet Reality: While Christ’s reign has begun, its fullness will only be realized in the new heavens and new earth. This aligns with amillennialism, which acknowledges both the present spiritual reign of Christ and the future consummation of all things.
In contrast, Dispensational premillennialism expects a future earthly kingdom where Christ physically rules over a restored Israel.
But such an interpretation conflicts with Jesus’ teaching about the nature of His kingdom and reduces its scope to a temporary, physical reality.
Isaiah’s Language Is Poetic and Symbolic
Isaiah 11 employs vivid imagery typical of Hebrew poetry, designed to convey deep spiritual truths rather than precise physical realities.
The peaceful coexistence of predators and prey, for example, symbolizes the harmony and reconciliation brought about by Christ’s reign.
Supporting Evidence:
- Symbolism in Isaiah: Elsewhere in Isaiah, poetic imagery communicates spiritual truths (e.g., Isaiah 2:2-4, where nations streaming to God’s mountain symbolizes global worship). Taking Isaiah 11’s imagery literally undermines the genre and the intention of the text.
- Revelation’s Use of Imagery: The book of Revelation, which premillennialists often associate with Isaiah 11, is filled with symbolic language (e.g., the lion of Judah, the Lamb of God). Isaiah 11’s imagery should be read in a similar symbolic way, pointing to spiritual realities rather than literal phenomena.
The Church as the Fulfillment of Israel
Amillennialism recognizes the unity of God’s redemptive plan.
Throughout Scripture, the Church is revealed as the fulfillment of God’s promises to Israel, a truth that is crucial for interpreting Isaiah 11.
Key Evidence:
- Galatians 3:28-29: Paul teaches that believers in Christ—whether Jew or Gentile—are the true heirs of Abraham’s promises. The Church is not a temporary “parenthesis” in God’s plan but the culmination of His covenantal promises.
- Romans 11: While this chapter may describe a future inclusion of ethnic Israel in God’s plan, it does so in the context of one people of God, the Church.
- 1 Peter 2:9-10: The Church inherits the titles once applied to Israel, such as “a chosen race” and “a royal priesthood.”
Isaiah 11’s promises about the restoration of Israel and the gathering of nations find their fulfillment in the Church, where God’s people are united under Christ, the true root of Jesse.
Theological Shortcomings of a Literalistic Premillennial Reading
Dispensational premillennialism often misreads Isaiah 11 by insisting on a strictly literal fulfillment.
Here’s why this approach is problematic:
- Forces a Dichotomy Between Israel and the Church: Dispensationalism views Israel and the Church as two distinct peoples with separate destinies. This contradicts the New Testament’s teaching that the dividing wall has been broken down in Christ (Ephesians 2:14-16).
- Ignores Progressive Revelation: Scripture is a unified story that moves toward fulfillment in Christ. By focusing on a future physical kingdom for Israel, Dispensationalism sidelines the way Christ fulfills these promises now in the Church.
- Overemphasizes Physical Realities: While physical renewal is part of God’s ultimate plan (Romans 8:21), Dispensationalism fixates on physical details (e.g., animal behavior, geopolitical events) that distract from the spiritual realities Isaiah emphasizes.
The Glory of Christ-Centered Interpretation
The amillennial approach magnifies Christ as the focal point of all Scripture.
It sees Isaiah 11 as a glorious vision of His kingdom, already inaugurated in His first coming and extending to the ends of the earth through the Church.
It avoids the pitfalls of literalism and recognizes the spiritual depth and unity of God’s redemptive plan.
Conclusion: A Better Way to Read Isaiah 11
Isaiah 11 is a rich and hope-filled prophecy, fulfilled in Jesus and His church.
Its promises of peace, righteousness, and reconciliation are already being realized in Christ’s reign and will be fully consummated at His return.
The amillennial reading honors the Bible’s overarching message, the nature of Christ’s kingdom, and the symbolic language of prophecy.
It invites us to see all of Scripture pointing to Christ and to live in the hope and joy of His already/not yet kingdom.
Leave a comment