Explaining The Book

About

The Abrahamic Covenant: Dispensationalism vs. Covenant Theology (Pedo- and Credo-baptist)

, ,
The Abrahamic Covenant: Dispensationalism vs. Covenant Theology (Pedo- and Credo-baptist)

The Abrahamic Covenant is central to understanding God’s redemptive plan, as it reveals His promises to Abraham and his descendants. How one interprets this covenant has significant implications for theology, especially regarding Israel, the Church, and the sacraments.


The Abrahamic Covenant in Scripture

The Abrahamic Covenant, found in Genesis 12:1-3, 15:1-21, and 17:1-8, includes several key promises:

  1. Land: God promised to give Abraham and his descendants the land of Canaan.
  2. Offspring: Abraham would have many descendants, including a singular “seed” through whom blessings would flow (Genesis 17:6; Galatians 3:16).
  3. Blessing: God promised to bless Abraham, make him a blessing, and bring blessings to all nations through him (Genesis 12:3).

This covenant was unconditional in that God took full responsibility for its fulfillment (Genesis 15:17), but the enjoyment of its blessings often included conditions, particularly for Abraham’s physical descendants (e.g., Genesis 17:1-2).


Dispensationalist Interpretation of the Abrahamic Covenant

Dispensationalism views the Abrahamic Covenant as containing literal, eternal promises to Abraham’s physical descendants (ethnic Israel) that remain distinct from God’s promises to the Church.

  1. Literal Land Promise: Dispensationalists believe God still owes the land of Canaan (and possibly more extensive territory) to ethnic Israel. While Israel has possessed the land historically, this possession has not yet fulfilled the covenant in its entirety. Dispensationalists often point to a future millennial kingdom where Israel will fully occupy the land as promised.
  2. Ethnic Focus: The promises of the Abrahamic Covenant (land, seed, blessing) are applied primarily to ethnic Israel. While the Church benefits from spiritual blessings (e.g., salvation), these blessings are distinct from Israel’s covenantal inheritance.
  3. Two Peoples of God: Dispensationalism often maintains a distinction between Israel and the Church. Israel’s promises remain physical and national, while the Church’s promises are spiritual and heavenly.
  4. Millennial Fulfillment: Many dispensationalists see the covenant as fully realized during the future millennial reign of Christ, where Israel will have preeminence among the nations.

Covenant Theology’s Interpretation of the Abrahamic Covenant

Covenant Theology views the Abrahamic Covenant as a key aspect of the overarching Covenant of Grace, emphasizing continuity between the Old and New Testaments. It sees the promises made to Abraham as ultimately fulfilled in Christ and His Church.

  1. Christ-Centered Fulfillment:
    • The land promise finds its ultimate fulfillment in the new heavens and new earth (Romans 4:13; Hebrews 11:10-16).
    • The “seed” of Abraham is primarily Christ (Galatians 3:16), and secondarily all who are united to Christ by faith (Galatians 3:7, 29).
    • The blessing to the nations is fulfilled in the gospel’s spread to all peoples, bringing salvation to both Jews and Gentiles.
  2. Unity of God’s People:
    • Covenant Theology teaches that Israel and the Church are one people of God, united in Christ. The Church does not replace Israel but is the continuation and fulfillment of Israel’s role as God’s covenant people (Ephesians 2:11-22).
  3. The Promises Expanded:
    • The promises of land, offspring, and blessing are not limited to physical, national Israel but have a broader, spiritual fulfillment in Christ. For example, the land promise extends to the whole world (Romans 4:13).

Pedo-Baptist vs. Credo-Baptist Perspectives Within Covenant Theology

While Covenant Theology is unified in its Christ-centered interpretation of the Abrahamic Covenant, pedo-baptists and credo-baptists differ on its implications for the sacrament of baptism, particularly concerning infants.

Pedo-Baptist View (e.g., Presbyterian and Reformed traditions):

  1. Continuity of the Covenant Community:
    • Pedo-baptists argue that the Abrahamic Covenant established a principle of including believers and their children in the covenant community (Genesis 17:7-9).
    • Just as the sign of circumcision was applied to infants under the Abrahamic Covenant, baptism—viewed as the sign of the New Covenant—should also be applied to infants of believing parents (Colossians 2:11-12).
  2. Covenantal Membership:
    • Children of believers are seen as part of the visible Church and are included in the covenant community by virtue of their parents’ faith. Baptism signifies their covenantal inclusion.
  3. Faith and Fulfillment:
    • Pedo-baptists stress that while baptism signifies covenant inclusion, it does not guarantee salvation. Covenant children must still come to personal faith in Christ to experience the covenant’s saving blessings.

Credo-Baptist View (e.g., Reformed Baptist tradition):

  1. Discontinuity in the Covenant Sign:
    • Credo-baptists agree that the Abrahamic Covenant foreshadows the New Covenant but emphasize differences between the two.
    • In the New Covenant, the sign of covenant membership (baptism) is reserved for those who profess faith in Christ (Acts 2:38-41; Matthew 28:19). Unlike circumcision, baptism signifies spiritual realities (e.g., regeneration and union with Christ) that require personal faith.
  2. The Church as the True Covenant Community:
    • Credo-baptists argue that the New Covenant is made only with the elect (Jeremiah 31:31-34; Hebrews 8:8-12). Therefore, only those who demonstrate saving faith are members of the covenant community and recipients of the covenant sign.
  3. The Abrahamic Covenant as Typological:
    • The physical elements of the Abrahamic Covenant (land, physical descendants, circumcision) are seen as types and shadows of greater spiritual realities in Christ. Credo-baptists believe that baptism reflects the fulfillment of these types and applies only to believers.

Conclusion

The Abrahamic Covenant is a cornerstone of God’s redemptive plan, pointing to Christ and His work of salvation.

  • Dispensationalists emphasize the covenant’s physical promises to ethnic Israel, anticipating a future literal fulfillment.
  • Covenant Theology sees the covenant as part of the broader Covenant of Grace, fulfilled in Christ and expanded to include all believers, Jew and Gentile.
  • Within Covenant Theology, pedo-baptists and credo-baptists agree on the covenant’s Christ-centered nature but differ on how its promises apply to the Church and the sign of baptism.

These interpretations reflect differing emphases on the unity of God’s redemptive plan, the role of Israel and the Church, and the nature of the covenant community.

Comments

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Discover more from Explaining The Book

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading